Looking for a new restaurant experience? The best way to find a fresh taste experience is by checking out reviews on Yelp. Fortunately, we’ve done the leg work for you! We’ve searched for the top-rated restaurants to bring you the best restaurants in Fish Creek, Sister Bay, and Egg Harbor based on positive reviews. Check out one of these local favorites this week.
🍕 Fish Creek Restaurants
Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille is located at 4023 State Hwy. 42 in Fish Creek, WI. This address is in the 54212 zip code area. For more information, call 920-868-3095. They are open Monday – Sunday from 11 AM – 10 PM. This restaurant has a 4.5-star rating with 444 reviews. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, you’ll want to visit this local favorite. Enjoy your meal inside or outside. You can create your own pizza with their fresh toppings or choose one of the specialty options. Specialty pizzas include Veggie, Smoked Pork BBQ, Margherita, and Sausage & Pesto. If you would like to have your meal do an extra bit of good, choose the Donation Creation (which changes each month) and $1. of the purchase price goes to a local non-profit organization. Other menu options include Grilled Veggies & Hummus, Terry’s Mac N’ Cheese, Artichoke Dip, and Chicken Tenders. Sandwich options include Korean Pulled Pork, Seared Tuna & Avocado Toast, and Cowboy Burger.
Blue Horse Beach Café is located at 4113 Main Street in Fish Creek, WI. This address is in the 54212 zip code area. For more information, call 920-868-1471. They are open Monday – Sunday from 7 AM – 5 PM. This restaurant has a 4.5-star rating with 135 reviews. Enjoy beautiful water views with your meal. Breakfast options include Sunrise Egg Sandwich, The Veg Out, Oatmeal, and Fruit Parfait. Lunch options include the Sweet Ham Sandwich, Roast Turkey Sandwich, Wasabi Garden Burger, Muffaletta, Curry Chicken Salad Sandwich, and BLT. Salad choices are Curry, Southwest, and Cranberry Pecan. The menu for kids features Pasta Salad Cup, Toasted Bagel, Grilled Cheese, Hot Ham & Cheese, and TLT. The best part? The whole menu is served all day!
🍾 Sister Bay Restaurants
Door County Creamery is located at 10653 N. Bay Shore Drive in Sister Bay, WI. This address is in the 54234 zip code area. For more information, call 920-854-3388. They are open Monday – Sunday from 10:30 AM – 9 PM. This restaurant has a 4.5-star rating with 102 reviews. This charming eatery serves food that is farm to fork. Take a spot at one of their outdoor tables if you want to enjoy the beautiful weather and atmosphere. You won’t find a traditional menu here. What you will find is a selection of food choices that are inspired by the season and their cheeses. They have an extensive selection of wine to enjoy with your cheese board, sandwich, salad, soup, or stuffed flatbread.
Grasse’s Grill is located at 10663 N. Bayshore Drive in Sister Bay, WI. This address is in the 54234 zip code area. For more information, call 920-854-1125. They are open seasonally (usually opening in May) everyday but Tuesday from 8 AM – 4 PM. This restaurant has a 4.5-star rating with 131 reviews. Visitors remark about the great atmosphere and friendly service here. Breakfast options include Brisket Hash, Bucky’s Burrito, Ellison Bluff Veggie Bowl, and Garrett Bay Granola Bowl. They also serve Buttermilk Pancakes, Grasse’s Biscuits & Gravy, and Sweet Biscuit Special. Lunch appetizers include Cheese Head Cheese Curds, Haystack Onions, and Chips & Salsa Basket. Grasse’s classic choices include Nana’s Mac N’ Cheese, Iva’s Meatloaf, and Chambers Island Honey Chicken. Sandwich options include Door County Veggie Wrap, Fish Tacos, and Cave Point Club Wrap.
🥞 Egg Harbor Restaurants
Village Café is located at 7918 State Hwy 42 in Egg Harbor, WI. This address is in the 54209 zip code area. For more information, call 920-868-3342. They are open Monday – Sunday from 7 AM – 2 PM. This restaurant has a 4-star rating with 106 reviews. If you love colorful settings, you’ll love this place! It’s bright and alive with color. They serve breakfast all day, but they also serve lunch and dinner. Breakfast options include Corned Beef Hash, The Scrambler Wrap, Healthy Granola, and Village Café Biscuits & Gravy. They also serve Pancakes, French Toast, and Omelets. Lunch sandwiches include Monte Cristo, Cali Club Croissant, Turkey Reuben, and Village Café Cherry Pecan Chicken Salad. Make sure you leave room for dessert!
MacReady Artisan Bread Company is located at 7838 Hwy 42 in Egg Harbor, WI. This address is in the 54209 zip code area. For more information, call 920-868-2233. They are open Thursday – Monday from 9 AM – 4 PM. This restaurant has a 4.5-star rating with 42 reviews. You want to take note of this restaurant if a picnic lunch sounds like a wonderful way to spend some time. They create delightful boxed lunches that come complete with a sandwich, housemade coleslaw and potato chips. Sandwich choices include Wisconsin Cranberry Chicken Salad, Farm Fresh Egg Salad, Marchant’s Double Smoked Ham & Cheddar, Seasonal Veggie, and Tuna Salad.